Humanities at the Crossroads: The Indiana case study

Editor’s Note: This is the fourth piece in a series on the “crisis” in the humanities. A post introducing the series can be found here.

Pottery wheel demonstration at Conner Prairie living history museum in Fishers, Indiana. Photo credit: Derek Jensen, Wikimedia Commons.

Pottery wheel demonstration at Conner Prairie living history museum in Fishers, Indiana.
Photo credit: Derek Jensen

In the past few years, the airwaves have been filled with angst about the state of the humanities, primarily in college and university humanities departments. Humanities at the Crossroads (HAC), a national initiative to examine the future of the humanities in American life, was one of several responses to the crisis. The HAC planning group, however, felt that more research was needed, and they decided to focus on a single state, Indiana, as a case study.

Indiana Humanities became the lead organization for the Indiana Case Study. What could we find out about the humanities in Indiana? It was like the KWL exercise that educators use: What do we know? What do we want to know? What did we learn?

Continue reading

Never let a (humanities) crisis go to waste

Flower featured in the film The Heart of the Matter: The Humanities and Social Sciences for a Vibrant, Competitive, and Secure Nation. Photo credit: American Academy of Arts and Sciences.

Flower featured in the film The Heart of the Matter: The Humanities and Social Sciences for a Vibrant, Competitive, and Secure Nation. Photo credit: American Academy of Arts and Sciences

Last August, fans of the Colbert Report saw Duke University President Richard Brodhead encourage study in the humanities as essential to a balanced education. The interview segment can be seen here. Brodhead’s appearance was part of a marketing campaign engineered by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences (AAAS) that was designed to advance support for the humanities in much the same way that the National Academy of Sciences had promoted Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM) with its 2007 report Rising above the Gathering Storm. Brodhead’s appearance may have been unusual for taking the case for humanities education to such a popular audience, but it reflected the AAAS’s conviction that a national dialogue on the importance of the humanities was necessary to its future. Continue reading

Taking public history for granted: A grant-writing guide for public historians

Sonya Lovine is a Sponsored Research Officer at California State University, Sacramento. She recently received her master’s degree in Public History from Sacramento State. For her thesis project, she wrote Taking Public History for Granted: A Grant-Writing Guide for Public Historians. H@W section editor Priya Chhaya asked her a few questions about the project and how it can be useful to public historians.

Why did you choose to develop this guide?

Photo credit: Penn Waggener, Wikimedia Commons

Photo credit: Penn Waggener, Wikimedia Commons

History brings immeasurable value to the public via various practices of public history. Everything that public history provides, though, requires some amount of financial resources. Executing a conservation plan, producing a traveling exhibit, or implementing a historic preservation plan all require funding. With a better understanding of the importance of grant-writing skills and the persistence to continually seek external funding, grant-seeking public historians can better share historical knowledge and contribute further to the growth of our society, culture, and nation. Public historians remain well aware of the importance and necessity of their profession, as well as the need for funding. The writing skills that they honed while studying to become historians provide the foundation for developing successful grant proposals. Continue reading

Is Deadwood gambling with history? (Part 2)

filling station

The recently destroyed Sinclair filling station, ca. 2013. Photo credit:  City of Deadwood Department of Planning and Preservation

Continued from Part 1.

Originally built in 1927, a small, unassuming Sinclair filling station on the edge of Main Street bespoke the pragmatic style of small rural industrial towns and stood as a monument to Deadwood’s mid-twentieth century history. It also survived a devastating fire that nearly destroyed the town in 1959. But over the years—and at least in part because the station did not comport with Deadwood’s dominant Wild West image—the Sinclair structure slipped into disrepair.

These events set the stage for the structure’s demise. In 2006, the owners of First Gold Hotel, a lucrative gaming resort, purchased the Sinclair station. This March, they razed it, claiming that time, disuse, and damage from a powerful blizzard last fall had stripped away the building’s historic value. Because the local Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) sanctioned the demolition, it might seem that the Sinclair station simply died of natural causes. Continue reading

Is Deadwood gambling with history? (Part I)

 

The close relationship between Deadwood’s gaming and a specific version of its history is clearly represented upon entering the town’s limits.  Photo credit: Patti McNeal

The close relationship between Deadwood’s gaming and a specific version of its history is clearly represented upon entering the town’s limits.
Photo credit: Patti McNeal

Twenty-five years ago, the state of South Dakota legalized commercial gaming within the boundaries of Deadwood, a small mining town nestled high in the Black Hills. Ever since, everyone from tourists and gamblers to film crews and rock stars have flooded its streets. The town’s unique history helped transform Deadwood into a hotbed for heritage tourism. As Jay D. Vogt, director of the South Dakota State Historical Society, recently wrote, “the colorful legends of Wild Bill Hickok and Calamity Jane,” two storied characters from the town’s brief flirtation with the “Wild West” of the 1870s, “make Deadwood a nationally recognized destination.” From 2004 to 2006, HBO even aired a popular television show set in (and named after) Deadwood, a portrayal which enhanced the town’s rugged visage and broadcast its regional past to national audiences. But community members and public historians, who have long struggled to make sure that Deadwood’s comfortable, tourist-friendly image includes diverse and critical perspectives on the past, have faced an additional challenge in recent months as at least one casino has destroyed a historic site in the name of expanding its business. Continue reading

The “new normal”: Is there one?

panel participants

Lee White and Angela Sirna during the “New Normal” panel. Photo credit: Max Van Balgooy

“Sequester” was a dirty word during last year’s conference season. At the March 2013 conference of the George Wright Society in Denver, attendance was down nearly 75 percent because of travel limitations put into place right before the meeting. At the National Council on Public History meeting in Ottawa a few weeks later, I noticed a number of my colleagues were absent. Travel cutbacks were just at the top of a long list of issues caused by the recession and then the across-the-board US federal budget cuts known as sequestration. I was deeply disturbed by what I saw in Denver, and this was before I watched the gates close at Catoctin Mountain Park (where I was working at the time) in October 2013 when the federal government shut down. I hoped that public historians could talk openly at this year’s meeting in Monterey and share responses to their “new normal.” Fortunately the program committee agreed, and on Thursday, March 20, we held an open conversation in a session titled “Situation Normal? Ways Past Sequestrations, Shutdowns, and Budgetary Woes.” Continue reading

What’s your new “Situation Normal”?

protester with sign

US federal government workers at an August 2013 protest of budget sequestration and employee furloughs. Photo credit: American Federation of Government Employees

As I sit down to write this post (and by the way, this is my first “official” history blog post), I am pondering what my “New Situation Normal” is as a public history practitioner for a federal agency. How has my work reality changed, for good and for ill, over the past 16 years? Certainly, technology and social media provide public historians with avenues to new and varied audiences. And with the Internet’s narrowing of time and space, interesting and exciting possibilities now exist for researchers and public historians.

However, there have been less positive workplace changes, namely budgetary and staffing constraints, which have created stresses and reprioritization at work for many American public historians in the public and private sector—as well as in other countries—regardless of agency or organization. Continue reading

Unpaid internships: A foot in the door or a step backward?

woman sowing coinsA recent History@Work post by Matthew Exline prompted a lively discussion of the challenges of getting a foot in the door as a new public history professional.  One topic that appeared several times in the many comments was the unpaid internship, and the opinions on it were divergent enough that we thought it was worth following up on them.   So we asked a number of practicing public historians from various areas of the field to share their thoughts on pursuing unpaid internships or volunteer opportunities as part of public historians’ professional training.

There’s no clear consensus, as you’ll see, but we hope this roundtable post will further clarify some of the issues and questions. Continue reading

Professional opportunities June 19, 2013

ANNCT: New community website for digital historians: join or start a group at Digital Historians.

ANNCT: National Coalition for History moves into social media realm with Facebook and Twitter

CFP: Papers on travel and tourism for MAPACA (Mid-Atlantic Popular/American Culture Assn.) , Nov. 7-9, 2013, Atlantic City, New Jersey, U.S.
DEADLINE: June 30, 2013

CFP: Chapters on “autobiography and trauma” and “gender and trauma” for edited collection on Mapping Generations of Traumatic Memory in American Narratives
DEADLINE: June 30, 2013

CFP: Historical Justice and Memory: Questions of Rights and Accountability in Contemporary Society, second annual conference of Columbia University’s Alliance for Historical Dialogue and Accountability/Dialogues on Historical Justice and Memory Network, Dec. 5-7, 2013, New York, New York, U.S.
DEADLINE: Sept. 5, 2013

CFP: The Archaeological Review seeks multidisciplinary contributions for its Archive Issue (November 2014)
DEADLINE: Oct. 30, 2013

CFP: Picturing the Family: Media, Narrative, Memory, July 10-11, 2014, London, U.K.
DEADLINE: Nov. 30, 2013

EDU: 4-week Museum Microclimates online course from Northern States Conservation Center begins July 1

EDU: Collections Camp: Costume and Textiles workshop from American Assn. for State and Local History, Kingston, Rhode Island, U.S. July 24-26, 2013
EARLY REGISTRATION by June 19, 2013

EDU: E-Workshop: Getting Started with Oral History from Baylor University Institute for Oral History, Aug. 7 and 14, 2013

FUNDING: New funding opportunities from U.S. National Endowment for the Humanities for media, historical, and cultural projects and organizations

DEADLINE: August 14, 2013

REV: Memory and Representation in Contemporary Europe (Kattago)